Question
Raising teenagers can be agonizing and difficult. Sometimes there is no clearly right answer in many dilemmas. The principle I keep in mind with teens 13 and older is that you can not supervise your daughter every moment. You need a rapport with her to stay involved in her life. Otherwise, a big part of her life will be beyond your reach. I think that in that portion of her life, you have no choice but to trust her.
Privacy is a big deal to teens, but must have limits. You are responsible if your daughter brings contraband of any kind into the house. I would do spot checks without her knowing about it. If you find something you are concerned about, check it out. Try not to put your anger into your voice or body language. Your anger carries a different message than you intend. She will hear your anger as a loss of love and acceptance.
Consider her words carefully, don't instantly challenge them as untrue. Check out her story as best you can before you gently confront her again.
Gently express your doubts. Act on them. Observe her eyes, are they blood shot, swollen? Is her behavior different than usual? Does she seem giddy or more distant or irritable than usual. Is she avoiding all contact with you, again more so than usual. How elaborate was her story? Did she provide much more detail than necessary to demonstrate her innocence? Smell her clothes and see if you detect a sweet pungent smell, certainly nothing like perfume. Smell and observe her fingers. The residue of smoking one marijuana cigarette or "joint" would be apparent if she hasn't washed her hands thoroughly.
Was the person she reported owned the rolling papers seemingly trustworthy? I agree that rolling your own cigarettes may make sense for a person strongly hooked on smoking who can't afford her habit. Very likely, you can smell cigarette smoke on her friend's or even your daughter's clothes. Call her friend's parents to verify the story.
She will be mad whether or not she lied. She might tip off a lie by quickly losing her angry tone. But don't in any way give her reason to doubt your love and concern.
Perhaps most importantly, monitor your voice tone and choice of words carefully. Stay calm and loving. Make sure your intensity of concern doesn't scare her into extreme defensiveness. Let her know, she is your daughter and you love her no matter what she does.
You may never be able to verify the truth each and every time. But remember, your rapport with her is key. It sounds like there has been a lot of conflict between you and your daughter. Go see a counselor with your daughter and try to mend fences. Note that you would like to learn how to handle these sorts of situations with her better in the future. And you want to be sure she feels safe to come to you if she needs to do so. Extreme measures are seldom helpful.
About the Expert
David Johnson
MSW, LICSW
Champlin, United States of America
Specialties
Dissociative Disorders, Anger Management, Gay Lesbian Issues, Personality Disorders, Child or Adolescent Issues, Divorce, Trauma and PTSD, Life Coaching, Psychosis, Mood Disorders, Parenting, Spirituality, Anxiety or Fears, Relationship Issues, Impulse Control Disorders, Elderly Persons Disorders, Women, Loss or Grief, Thinking Disorders, Depression, Finding Your Purpose in Life
License
my_license #2338
