The Importance of Harm Reduction Programs: Why Abstinence-Only Programs Aren’t Enough
Some drug users are willing to get help but aren't ready to quit at this moment. Recognizing this, harm reduction programs exist to minimize the health, economic and social costs of drug use at the personal and community levels.
It would be pretty nice to rid the world of drug addiction and all of its negative personal and societal consequences.
Unfortunately, no one has any idea of how to do that, despite herculean efforts like the prohibition-style war on drugs that have accomplished very little in actually reducing drug use and abuse!
So if we admit that at the community level we cannot stop drug use and abuse, do we then simply turn a blind eye to the needs and suffering of the tens of millions of Americans who use licit and illicit drugs and the hundreds of millions of Americans who love them as sisters and mothers, fathers and brothers?
Or do we take action to help those who are ready to quit using with effective addiction treatments and interventions and to support the left-over majority with evidence-based initiatives which reduce the personal harms and risks of drug use and which protect communities from some of the fall-out consequences?
The question is – are we ready to look at the facts and to base action on science rather than emotion and to see those who require our help as people like us deserving our compassion rather than our punishments?
Principles of Harm Reduction
Harm reduction is an umbrella term for initiatives which strive to reduce the individual and societal harms associated with drug use. Some common principles of harm reduction programs include:
- Accepting that drug use is an enduring part of our communities, whether we like it or not, but knowing that though we cannot rid the world of drug use we can take steps to reduce the harms associated with drug use.
- Accepting that drug users are deserving of the same human rights, dignity and compassion as anyone else
- Accepting that people who cannot or will not stop using drugs can still make good choices to protect themselves from unnecessary harm1
- Meeting drug users ‘where they are’. Not trying to convince drug users to seek treatments which they do not want but working with them to help them make small improvements in areas like personal health, employment, crime prevention etc.
- Accepting that some ways of using drugs are safer than other ways, and that helping people to use drugs in safer ways can save lives and reduce harms
- Understanding that people are much more likely to make
changes in small steps rather than in giant leaps and most commonly, major life
changes are made through a series of many small steps. It makes sense to
support people in making these small positive steps and not to only support
major leaps (like going from injection drug use to sudden abstinence). At the
societal level, there can be greater benefit from helping many people make
small improvements than in helping a motivated few make great improvements. 2
- Evaluating a harm reduction program’s success by the degree it improves life at the individual or societal level, whether or not the initiative results in a reduction in drug use.3
- Being committed to using the strongest available evidence to justify a course of action and to seeking the greatest possible benefit through programs that maximize impact and minimize costs
Examples of Different Types of Harm Reduction Programs
Some examples of harm reduction programs include:
- Needle or crack pipe exchange programs
- The use of methadone or Suboxone
- Providing condoms to sex workers
- Supervised injection clinics
- Designated driver programs
- Health outreach programs
- Street drug testing (such as testing for the purity of ecstasy in a club to prevent inadvertent overdose or use of a more dangerous drug)
- HIV testing and counseling services
- Care for wounds (injection drug related)
- Peer drug use information outreach programs
Evidence for the Effectiveness of Harm Reduction Policies
- A study of injection drug use harm reduction programs found no convincing evidence that needle exchange programs increased injection drug use (one criticism of certain types of harm reduction programs is that they encourage drug use, however research rarely finds evidence to back these assertions.)4 A separate review of 42 studies on the use of needle exchange programs found that these programs were associated with reducing the reuse of injection equipment, reducing the frequency of injecting, reducing the frequency of crack cocaine use, increasing referrals for substance abuse treatment and increasing the use of condoms.5
- A review study of harm reduction programs found that methadone maintenance programs were effective in retaining opiate dependent people in treatment and in reducing illicit drug use and crime participation. This same review study also found that needle exchange programs were a very cost effective way to reduce the transmission of HIV among injection drug users.6
- A study in published in The Lancet medical journal found that fatal overdoses were down by 35% within 500 meters of the Insite safe injection facility in Vancouver since its opening, compared to a reduction of only 9% across the rest of the city.7
References
- 1. Open Society Foundations: Drug Use and Public Health
- 2. Harm Reduction International: What Is Harm Reduction? (ihra.net, 2014)
- 3. Harm Reduction.org: Principles of Harm Reduction
- 4. The Effectiveness of Harm Reduction in Preventing HIV among Injecting Drug Users.
- 5. EMCDDA - Harm reduction: evidence, impacts and challenges
- 6. A Review of the Evidence-Base for Harm Reduction Approaches to Drug Use
- 7. Reduction in Overdose Mortality after the Opening of North America’s First Medically Supervised Safer Injecting Facility
Editor’s picks
Children Living with Addicted Parents – Spotting Neglect and Knowing When to Intervene
Children living with drug or alcohol addicted parents may experience neglect and endangerment. Here are 13 situations that warrant outside intervention.
Adult Children of Alcoholics and Addicts: Haven’s Story
As we focus on adults in recovery from addiction, we often overlook the needs of their children. In many cases they have to find their own way.
Your Legal Rights To Confidential Drug Treatment
You have a legal right to confidential treatment, and you cannot be discriminated against on the job, in the housing market, or for access to any governmental programs. Find out what your rights are, and get help today.
Infectious Disease Risks Associated with Drug Use and Abuse
Unfortunately, the damage done through drug abuse far exceeds the sometimes substantial destruction of the drug alone, and can also include infectious diseases and other health risks. Don't risk your health and happiness for a few hours of dwindling pleasure; get help and get better today.
Alcohol Policies and Laws to Reduce Alcohol-Related Harms – Which Programs Work and Which Programs Don’t
Although a legal substance, a lot of legislation regulates how we can buy, sell and consume alcohol – and this is understandable, since alcohol misuse costs Americans an estimated $223.5 billion per year. Find out what types of alcohol polices actually work well to reduce the harms of excessive alcohol use and which ones – though they may sound good – do not work very well at all.