Text Size

Depressed Woman Caught Smiling on Facebook Gets Medical Benefits Cancelled

posted 10:40 PM EST, Tue December 01, 2009

A Canadian women who had been receiving disability checks for serious depression was told to get back to work because of pictures on her facebook page that show her smiling and laughing.

Natalie Blanchard, 29, from Quebec Canada, had been on medical leave from her job at IBM for 18 months, when suddenly and without warning, her disability payments stopped coming.

She contacted her employer’s insurance provider, Manulife, and was told that “I’m available to work because of facebook.”

Blanchard’s insurance company had reviewed public domain information from her facebook profile and on it they found pictures of her on vacation and at a Chippendales show, amongst other social outings. In the pictures, she looks like she’s having a lot of fun, which Manulife implies is at odds with her diagnosis of clinical depression.

Blanchard won’t deny the photos but says that although she can sometimes be happy, “in the moment” her depressive symptoms linger on. Anyway, she counters, the trips she took that are being used against her were suggested by her doctor as ‘curative’ voyages, designed to get her to have a bit of fun.

People with atypical depression typically experience mood reactivity – which is an ability to experience pleasure in some situations.

Blanchard has filed a civil suit with the Quebec Superior Court, seeking the reinstatement of her benefits.

Manulife isn’t talking about the specifics of the Blanchard case, but said in a statement, "We would not deny or terminate a valid claim solely based on information published on websites such as Facebook."

Email It Send this page Print It Print friendly page Subscribe Subscribe to this topic category
Creative Commons License
Copyright Notice
We welcome republishing of our content on condition that you credit Choose Help and the respective authors. This article is licensed under a Creative Commons License.

Join Thousands of Readers

who receive our weekly recovery newsletter.

Helpful Information
Overcoming Depression: Feeling Good Again with Mindfulness
Mindfulness and Depression: Learning to Feel Good Again © Premasagar
How Mindfulness can overcome depression, teach us how to ignore unwanted thoughts and help us choose what is healthy for ourselves. Read Article
Depression Treatment July 07, 2015 (1)
Use Gut Bacteria to Fight Anxiety and Depression
Gut Bacteria Protect Your Mental Health. Learn How to Protect Your Microbiome © NIAID
Imbalanced gut bacteria may increase your risk of anxiety, depression, obesity and a host of other diseases. Learn how digestive bacteria can cause anxiety and find out how dietary changes can help you instill or protect an optimal balance of beneficial bacteria. Read Article
Co-Occurring Disorders May 26, 2016
Dealing with Depression and Chronic Pain Learn how opioids can lead to depression, how depression worsens pain and what to do when you have both pain and depression. Read Article
Pain & Opioid Issues April 07, 2015
Like Our Site? Follow Us!

This website is certified by Health On the Net Foundation. Click to verify. This site complies with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health information:
verify here.